Home › Blog › Tile to Tin Roofing

Tile to Tin Roofing: What Switching From Tile to Metal Involves

Why owners trade tile for metal, how the two compare on cost, weight and hail, what the job involves, and when a tile re-lay is the better call.

Clay tile, average
$22.21 / sq ft
US average, installed
Metal, average
$19.30 / sq ft
US average, installed
Clay tile weight
700 to 1,000 lb
per 100 sq ft of roof

Sources: This Old House new roof cost guide (updated October 7, 2026) and clay tile roof guide (updated June 5, 2026). National figures, not Bluebonnet prices.

Tile to tin roofing means taking a clay or concrete tile roof off a house and putting a metal roof in its place. "Tin roof" is what most people in Texas call any metal roof, but the panels on homes today are almost always coated steel. The switch is common on older tile roofs whose underlayment has worn out, and it changes three things at once: the weight on the framing, the look of the house and how the roof handles hail. This guide covers what the swap involves, what it costs compared with staying with tile, and how to decide.

If you are already leaning toward metal, our standing seam metal roofing page explains how we scope one, starting with a free inspection by the owner.

Stone home with a dark bronze standing seam metal roof, a timber-framed entry porch and a black pickup in the driveway
A dark standing seam metal roof on a stone home. Darker metal colors sit well with stone and brick.

What's in this guide

What "tin roof" means today

Real tin has not been a common roofing metal for a long time. When someone around Fort Worth asks about a tin roof, they nearly always mean a steel roof, either the ribbed screw-down panels you see on barns and shops or standing seam panels with raised seams and hidden clips. This Old House calls steel the most common and most affordable metal for roofing, often with a zinc or aluminum coating against rust. Aluminum and copper are also made into roof panels, but they are far less common on houses.

On a home that has had tile, most owners choose standing seam. It has no rows of exposed screws, the panels run in one piece from eave to ridge, and it reads as a finished roof on a stone or stucco house. Screw-down panels cost less but look like a farm building, and every screw is a seal that ages in the sun. Our metal roof cost guide covers the price gap between the two styles.

Why people switch from tile to metal

Clay tile itself lasts a very long time. This Old House puts a clay tile roof at more than 100 years when it is installed properly.

The problem is usually what is under the tile. The underlayment beneath a tile roof does much of the waterproofing, and on many older tile roofs it wears out well before the tiles do. When that layer fails, the honest options are to lift the tile, replace the underlayment and lay the tile back, or to take the tile off for good and put on a different roof.

Owners who choose metal at that point usually give one of these reasons:

  • Broken tiles. Tiles crack from hail, from falling limbs and from people walking on them to work on a satellite dish or an AC line. Finding matching replacements for an older tile can be hard.
  • Weight. This Old House puts clay tile at 700 to 1,000 pounds per roofing square (100 square feet). Metal panels weigh far less, so the switch takes load off the framing rather than adding it.
  • A new look. Standing seam suits farmhouse, ranch and modern designs, and some owners simply want the house to look different.
  • Maintenance. A metal roof can be walked on carefully by a roofer without cracking anything, which makes later work on vents, skylights or solar simpler.

Tile vs metal at a glance

ComparedClay tileMetal (steel standing seam)
Average cost, installed$22.21 / sq ft$19.30 / sq ft
Expected lifespan50 to 100 years40 to 70 years
Weight700 to 1,000 lb per 100 sq ftFar lighter
HailIndividual tiles can crackLarge hail can dent panels
HeatEPA lists terra cotta as naturally coolCool-pigment paints raise reflectance
Walkable for repairsOnly with care, tiles breakYes, with care

Sources: This Old House, "How Much Does a New Roof Cost?" (updated October 7, 2026) for cost and lifespan; This Old House clay tile roof guide (updated June 5, 2026) for weight; EPA, "Using Cool Roofs to Reduce Heat Islands" (updated June 18, 2026) for heat.

Both materials are long-lived. The real differences are weight, how each one fails in a hailstorm, and what the house looks like afterward.

What the switch costs

On national averages, a new metal roof and a new clay tile roof land in the same range. This Old House puts clay tile at $22.21 per square foot installed and metal at $19.30.

The Metal Roofing Alliance, the metal roofing industry's trade group, says the same thing in plainer words: a metal roof is comparable in price to tile. So the choice is rarely about saving money on the new roof. It is about which roof you want for the next few decades.

What a tile to metal job adds is the tear-off. Tile is heavy, slow to remove and bulky to haul away.

This Old House's tile roof guide (updated April 10, 2026) puts old roof removal at $1 to $6 per square foot, plus a dumpster. On a 2,500 square foot roof, that is roughly $2,500 to $15,000 before the new roof starts. Ask for the tear-off and haul-away as their own line on any quote.

For a rough budget, take your roof area, multiply by a metal price per square foot from our metal roof cost guide, and add the removal. Then get a measured quote, because the shape of the roof decides more of the price than the panel does.

What happens on a tile to metal job

  1. Inspection. The roofer looks at the tile, the flashing and, where possible, the underlayment, and measures every slope. This is also the time to talk about panel style, color and gauge.
  2. Tear-off. The tile, the battens it hung on, if any, and the old underlayment come off down to the roof deck.
  3. Deck check. With the deck bare, damaged or soft sheathing from past leaks can be found and replaced. A tile roof that leaked for a while often has a few spots like this.
  4. Underlayment. A new underlayment suited to metal goes down. It is the backup layer if water ever gets past a seam or flashing.
  5. Panels and trim. Panels are formed to the length of each slope and clipped down, then the eave, rake, ridge, valley and wall trim go on. On a former tile roof, the walls, chimneys and any parapets need new flashing made for metal.
Drone view looking straight down at a long home with a red clay tile roof, a lower flat roof section and a pool, surrounded by bare trees
From above, a tile roof shows how many hips, valleys and roof-to-wall joints a switch has to re-flash.

One thing to check before you choose: if your home is in a neighborhood with a homeowners association, read the deed restrictions or ask the HOA. Some subdivisions specify roof materials or colors, and a change from tile can need approval first.

When keeping the tile makes more sense

Switching is not always the right call. If the tiles are in good shape and the leak is in the underlayment or the flashing, the tile can often come up, the underlayment underneath can be replaced, and the same tile can go back down. That keeps the look of the house and avoids buying a new roof covering. Tile also suits Spanish and Mediterranean-style homes in a way metal cannot copy, and on some houses changing the roof changes the whole character of the place.

Repair-first is also how we work on tile. Our tile, slate and copper roofing page explains how we inspect a tile roof and when a repair or a re-lay will hold.

Hail and insurance in North Texas

Hail is part of owning a roof around Fort Worth, and neither material is immune. A large hailstone can crack a clay tile, and it can dent a metal panel even if the roof still sheds water. The Texas Department of Insurance says roofing materials tested for impact resistance are rated Class 1 to 4, that a Class 4 roof covering gets the highest premium credit, and that each insurer sets its own discount (TDI roofing discounts, as of February 24, 2023). Before you choose, ask your insurer what it offers, and ask any roofer for the impact rating of the exact product in the quote.

How we price a tile to metal switch

At Bluebonnet Construction & Roofing, owner Cody Taylor inspects and measures the roof and writes every estimate himself. The inspection is free, and the written estimate comes to your email. Because we work on both tile and standing seam metal, we can price both paths on your house: a tile re-lay or repair, and a full switch to metal. You get real numbers side by side instead of a sales pitch for one of them.

We look at tile and metal roofs across our area, including Aledo, Willow Park, Hudson Oaks, Granbury and Fort Worth. To get both options priced, request a free inspection from our standing seam metal roofing page.

FAQ

Can you put a metal roof over a tile roof?

No. Tile is heavy, uneven and brittle, so metal panels cannot be laid flat over it. The tile, any battens and the old underlayment come off first, the roof deck is checked, and the metal roof goes on over new underlayment.

Is a metal roof cheaper than a tile roof?

Usually about the same. This Old House puts a clay tile roof at $22.21 per square foot installed and metal at $19.30, and the Metal Roofing Alliance says metal is comparable in price to tile. Switching from tile adds the cost of tearing the tile off and hauling it away.

Is a metal roof lighter than tile?

Yes, by a wide margin. This Old House puts clay tile at 700 to 1,000 pounds per 100 square feet of roof. A metal roof weighs far less, so moving from tile to metal takes load off the framing rather than adding it.

What is a tin roof?

Today a tin roof almost always means a steel roof. Real tin is rarely used. On homes, the two common styles are screw-down ribbed panels and standing seam panels, which hide their fasteners under raised seams.

Can an old tile roof be repaired instead of replaced?

Often, yes. When the tiles are sound and the leak comes from worn underlayment or flashing, the tile can be lifted, new underlayment put down and the same tile laid back. Whether that will hold depends on what an inspection finds.

Does a metal roof hold up to hail?

It still sheds water after most hail, but large hailstones can dent the panels. Clay tile can crack instead. The Texas Department of Insurance says impact-rated roofing is graded Class 1 to 4, and a Class 4 covering gets the highest premium credit, with each insurer setting its own discount.

Get a Free Inspection

Free roof inspections across Parker, Tarrant, Hood and Johnson counties. We will call you back to set a time.