Home › Blog › Types of Roofing Materials

Different Types of Roofing Materials: A Guide for North Texas Homes

Shingle, metal, tile, slate, wood and synthetic roofing side by side: what each costs, how long it lasts, what it weighs and which houses it suits.

Lowest up-front cost
Asphalt shingle
About $5.16 / sq ft installed
Middle ground
Metal
About $19.30 / sq ft, 40 to 70 years
Longest lived
Slate and tile
50 to 150 years

Source: This Old House new roof cost guide (updated October 7, 2026). National averages for builder-grade materials, not Bluebonnet prices.

The different types of roofing materials for a house come down to a handful of families: asphalt shingles, metal, clay and concrete tile, slate, wood shakes, and newer synthetic products made to look like slate or shake. Flat and low-slope roofs use membranes instead. Each one trades up-front cost against lifespan, weight and looks, and in North Texas, against how it handles hail and summer heat.

This guide compares the common residential roofing materials side by side, with sourced prices and lifespans, and explains which ones suit which houses. If you are replacing a roof soon, our roof replacement page explains how we price more than one option on the same house.

Drone view of a large lake home with a brown architectural shingle roof, several dormers and wings, and a lake and boat docks behind it
Architectural asphalt shingles on a large home with many wings and dormers. Shingle handles a cut-up roof shape like this at the lowest cost.

What's in this guide

Roofing materials compared

This Old House publishes both installed prices and expected lifespans for the main materials. The first four rows come from its 2026 new roof cost guide; concrete tile and slate come from its tile roof cost guide, which gives ranges rather than averages.

MaterialInstalled cost per sq ftExpected lifespanWeight
Asphalt shingle$5.16 average30 to 35 yearsLight
Wood shake$13.15 average30 to 50 yearsLight
Metal$19.30 average40 to 70 yearsLight
Clay tile$22.21 average50 to 100 yearsHeavy
Concrete tile$7 to $1950 years or moreHeavy
Slate$10 to $4575 to 150 yearsHeavy

Sources: This Old House, "How Much Does a New Roof Cost?" (updated October 7, 2026) and This Old House tile roof cost guide (updated April 10, 2026).

Two things stand out. The cheapest roof up front is also the shortest-lived, and the heavy materials (tile and slate) last the longest but need a roof frame built to carry them. Most homeowners end up choosing between shingle and metal, or staying with tile or slate because the house was built for it.

Asphalt shingles

Asphalt shingles cover a great many houses in North Texas because they cost the least to install, suit almost any style, and are quick to repair. They come in two main types:

  • Three-tab shingles are the older, flat style: a single layer cut into three tabs, which gives the roof an even, flat look.
  • Architectural shingles are made from more than one layer bonded together, so they are thicker, give the roof depth and shadow lines, and come in more colors.

Shingles are also made in impact-rated versions. The Texas Department of Insurance (TDI) says impact-tested roof coverings are rated Class 1 to 4, and a Class 4 roof covering receives the highest premium credit from insurers that offer one. Ask your insurer before you choose. For prices by roof size, see our roof replacement cost guide.

Metal roofing

Metal roofs on houses come in two broad styles. Standing seam panels lock together along raised seams with the fasteners hidden underneath, which gives a clean look that suits farmhouse, ranch and modern homes. Exposed-fastener panels are screwed through the face, cost less, and are common on barns, shops and some homes. Metal also comes stamped to look like shingles or tile.

Metal weighs far less than tile, sheds water fast, and lasts 40 to 70 years in This Old House's figures. It costs more up front than shingle and can dent in large hail even when it keeps the water out. Our metal roof cost guide breaks down the price by style and size, and our metal roofing page explains how we install it.

Two-story stucco lake home with a green standing seam metal roof over two levels of arched covered porches
A green standing seam metal roof on a two-story home. The raised seams run from ridge to eave with no screws showing on the face of the panels.

Clay and concrete tile

Clay tile is fired clay, most often the terracotta color that suits Spanish and Mediterranean-style homes. Concrete tile is molded and costs less, and it can be made to look like clay, slate or wood. Both are heavy, and This Old House notes that natural tile materials usually need additional roof support, which is why a house that has never carried tile needs its framing checked before tile goes on.

On a tile roof, the tile itself is very durable, but the underlayment beneath it does much of the waterproofing and often wears out first. Our roofing tile types guide covers profiles and colors, and our roofing tile cost guide covers prices.

Stone Mediterranean-style home with a multi-tone clay tile roof stepping down from a two-story tower to a single-story wing
Multi-tone clay tile on a stone Mediterranean-style home. Tile suits this style of house and lasts for decades when the underlayment beneath it is kept in good shape.

Slate and copper

Slate is natural stone, split into thin pieces and hung on the roof one at a time. It suits Tudor and French-style homes and can last well over a century, but it is the heaviest and slowest material to install and repair, and that shows in the price.

Copper is the specialty metal. It is used for whole roofs on a few homes and more often for accents: bay window roofs, turrets, valleys and flashing. It weathers from bright copper to brown and eventually to a green patina. Both are specialty work, covered on our tile, slate and copper roofing page.

Wood shakes and synthetic shingles

Wood shakes, usually cedar, give a rustic look and last 30 to 50 years in This Old House's figures, but they need more upkeep than the other materials and cost more than asphalt.

Synthetic or composite shingles are made from plastics and rubber and molded to look like slate or shake. This Old House's tile guide puts composite tile at $12 to $26 per square foot installed and notes that it is lightweight, which makes it an option when the look of slate is wanted on a frame that cannot carry stone.

Flat and low-slope roofs

Shingles and tile need slope to shed water. Flat and low-slope sections, such as a porch roof, an addition or a commercial building, use membranes like TPO, EPDM or modified bitumen instead. Our commercial roofing types guide compares them.

Choosing a material for a North Texas home

Hail

Hail is the biggest outside factor on a North Texas roof. No material is hail-proof, but they fail differently: shingles bruise and lose granules, tile can crack, and metal can dent while still keeping water out. Impact ratings are the one objective comparison, and TDI's roofing discount page explains how insurers credit Class 4 coverings.

Heat

Summer sun is hard on roofs. The EPA notes that cool roof options exist for steep roofs in every material family: shingles with light or cool-colored granules, naturally cool terra cotta tile, metal with reflective coatings, and wood shakes. It says cool roofs can lower peak indoor temperatures by 2.2 to 5.9°F in homes without air conditioning.

The house and its frame

Style matters: tile suits Mediterranean homes, slate suits Tudor and French styles, and standing seam suits farmhouse and ranch homes. Weight matters more. Moving from shingle to tile or slate means checking the framing first, while moving from tile to metal takes weight off. Our tile to tin roofing guide covers that switch.

How we help you choose

Bluebonnet Construction & Roofing installs asphalt shingle, standing seam metal, clay tile, slate and copper, so we can price more than one option on your actual house and let you compare. A replacement is the easiest time to change material, because the old roof is coming off anyway.

Owner Cody Taylor inspects every roof and writes every estimate himself. The inspection is free, and the written estimate comes to your email and names exactly what is going on the roof. We work in Aledo, Fort Worth, Weatherford, Benbrook, Granbury and the rest of our service area. Start on our roof replacement page.

Other sources: TDI roofing discounts (as of February 24, 2023); EPA, "Using Cool Roofs to Reduce Heat Islands" (updated June 18, 2026).

FAQ

What are the different types of roofing materials?

For houses, the main types are asphalt shingles (three-tab and architectural), metal (standing seam and exposed-fastener), clay and concrete tile, slate, wood shakes and synthetic or composite shingles. Flat and low-slope roofs use membranes such as TPO, EPDM or modified bitumen.

What is the cheapest roofing material?

Asphalt shingle. This Old House puts it at about $5.16 per square foot installed in 2026, against about $19.30 for metal and $22.21 for clay tile. It also has the shortest expected lifespan of the main materials, at 30 to 35 years.

What is the longest-lasting roofing material?

Slate, at 75 to 150 years in This Old House's figures, followed by clay tile at 50 to 100 years and metal at 40 to 70. The underlayment and flashing under tile and slate usually need attention long before the stone or tile itself wears out.

What roofing material is best for hail in Texas?

No material is hail-proof. The most objective comparison is the impact rating: the Texas Department of Insurance says impact-tested roof coverings are rated Class 1 to 4, and a Class 4 covering receives the highest premium credit from insurers that offer one. Ask your insurer what it credits before you choose.

Can I switch from shingles to metal or tile?

Yes. A replacement is the easiest time, because the old roof comes off anyway. Metal is light and goes on most framing. Tile and slate are heavy, so the roof framing should be checked, and sometimes reinforced, before they go on.

Get a Free Inspection

Free roof inspections across Parker, Tarrant, Hood and Johnson counties. We will call you back to set a time.